تارىخىم
EN
Theme
Text size
Disputed questions

Disputed · views side by side

In which year was Osman Batur born?

This question belongs to Osman Batur

Disputed · views side by side

Most widely accepted view

1899

Ömer Kul (2009): 1899, at Öndirkara on the Irtysh in Köktogay, in the Altai. Millward and Forbes also give 1899.

Ömer Kul, Osman Batur ve Doğu Türkistan Millî Mücadelesi (1941–1951), doctoral thesis, İstanbul Üniversitesi (2009) · James A. Millward, Eurasian Crossroads: A History of Xinjiang (London: Hurst, 2007) · Andrew D. W. Forbes, Warlords and Muslims in Chinese Central Asia (1986)

1889

Hızırbek Gayretullah (quoted by Ömer Kul), from people of his village: 1889.

Ömer Kul, Osman Batur ve Doğu Türkistan Millî Mücadelesi (1941–1951), doctoral thesis, İstanbul Üniversitesi (2009)

1898

Altay (quoted by Ömer Kul): 1898.

Ömer Kul, Osman Batur ve Doğu Türkistan Millî Mücadelesi (1941–1951), doctoral thesis, İstanbul Üniversitesi (2009)

The other views are shown with their own sources.

Disputed · views side by side

On which day was Osman Batur executed?

Most widely accepted view

29 April 1951

Ömer Kul (2009): Sunday 29 April 1951, in Ürümqi. Forbes also gives April 1951.

Ömer Kul, Osman Batur ve Doğu Türkistan Millî Mücadelesi (1941–1951), doctoral thesis, İstanbul Üniversitesi (2009) · Andrew D. W. Forbes, Warlords and Muslims in Chinese Central Asia (1986)

28 April 1951

İsa Yusuf Alptekin and others (quoted by Ömer Kul): 28 April 1951, after a 'people's trial' before 90,000 people. Ürümqi radio put the trial on 28 April and reported the execution the next day.

Ömer Kul, Osman Batur ve Doğu Türkistan Millî Mücadelesi (1941–1951), doctoral thesis, İstanbul Üniversitesi (2009)

1 May 1951

Zakenuli and Hakim Kırımlı (quoted by Ömer Kul): 1 May 1951.

Ömer Kul, Osman Batur ve Doğu Türkistan Millî Mücadelesi (1941–1951), doctoral thesis, İstanbul Üniversitesi (2009)

The other views are shown with their own sources.

Sources (3)

Where next?

Report an error

Do not include anything that identifies you or your family.