تارىخىم
EN
Theme
Text size

Disputed questions

Questions historians answer differently. Each view comes with its own source; the green one is the most widely accepted, or the one Tarixim follows.

Big questions

8 questions

The Protector-General of the Western Regions · 60 BC

What does 60 BCE mean for the region?

Mehmet Emin Buğra (1940)· Researcher· The view Tarixim follows

The years 59–10 BCE were China's first invasion of East Turkistan.

Official sources of the People's Republic of China· Official statement

The region has been part of China since 60 BCE.

+1 more views, with sources →

The Ghulja rising · 1944

What was the Ghulja rising?

Ömer Kul (2009)· The view Tarixim follows

A national rising that began in Nilka; its leadership was soon taken over by Ehmetjan Qasimi's Soviet-backed committee, and the republic soon became a Soviet puppet.

The Chinese Nationalist government and its officers

A rising made by the Soviet Union.

+3 more views, with sources →

The Ghulja leaders vanish on the way to Beijing · 1949

Was there really a plane crash?

The Chinese authorities (December 1949)· Most widely accepted view

On 27 August the plane hit a mountain near Lake Baikal and everyone on board died.

Dillon (quoted by Ömer Kul)

The crash happened in early 1950, with eight people on board.

+3 more views, with sources →

The Chinese government (2002 white paper, as cited by Millward)· Official statement

A 'serious riot' organised by terrorist groups; from 5 to 8 February seven innocent people were killed and 200 injured.

Amnesty International and Uyghur groups (as cited by Millward)· Organisation's report

A protest against the ban on mäshräp gatherings and against arrests; police fired on the marchers and hundreds were detained.

Read with sources →

The Chinese government (2009 white paper)· Official statement

It was masterminded by terrorist, separatist and extremist forces inside and outside China.

Human Rights Watch (2009)· Organisation's report

The protest against the killing of Uyghur workers in Guangdong appears to have begun peacefully; the authorities blamed outside forces but gave no evidence; many analysts see the root causes in long-standing discriminatory policies.

Read with sources →

2017–2019: the detention system · 2017

What was the detention system of 2017–2019?

The Chinese government (2019 white paper)· Official statement

'vocational education and training centres' giving free residential training to people involved in minor offences, to prevent terrorism and extremism; trainees graduate when they reach the required standard.

The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights (2022)· Organisation's report

A pattern of large-scale arbitrary detention, at least from 2017 to 2019, affecting a significant proportion of Uyghurs and other mainly Muslim groups, which 'may constitute international crimes, in particular crimes against humanity'.

+2 more views, with sources →

Differences in dates

15 questions