When were the Ancient Letters written?
Disputed · views side by side
312 – 313
W. B. Henning (as reported by Sims-Williams; generally accepted): 312–313, since the sack of Luoyang and Ye in letter 2 fits the events of 307 and 311.
Nicholas Sims-Williams, “Ancient Letters”, Encyclopaedia Iranica II/1 (1985)
313 – 314
Millward: most scholars agree on 313–314.
James A. Millward, Eurasian Crossroads: A History of Xinjiang (London: Hurst, 2007)
100 – 150
Aurel Stein: before about the middle of the 2nd century, when the frontier garrisons were withdrawn.
Nicholas Sims-Williams, “Ancient Letters”, Encyclopaedia Iranica II/1 (1985)
190 – 196
J. Harmatta: just after an earlier sack of Luoyang in 190.
Nicholas Sims-Williams, “Ancient Letters”, Encyclopaedia Iranica II/1 (1985)
The views stand side by side; the reader decides.




